The genre of laments (both individual and communal) can be traced historically, even up to today, to periods of crisis. The psalms of lament in the Hebrew Bible point to periods both of national crisis such as wars, exile, and individual crisis, namely attacks from enemies and illness among others. The crisis of the exile was typified by death (in the literal and metaphorical sense), pestilence, disease and war. It was also typified by hope as some of the prophets such as Jeremiah could prophesy both doom (read: death) and salvation (read: hope). If there is any crisis that people of African descent, particularly those located within the sub-Saharan continent, have ever come to experience it is the crisis brought by the pandemic of HIV and AIDS. The pandemic is better approached by scholars who hold the view that it is multisectoral. According to the latter view, the pandemic impacts the social, the economic, the religious or spiritual, and the psychological lives of both the affected and the infected. It is a justice issue. It can thus not be relegated to the individual because it is communal. Is it any wonder that in 2002 the members of the
The search for a readily identifiable situation as the context for understanding the laments may, however, be illusory or unnecessary. The language of these psalms with its stereotypical, generalizing, and figurative style is so open-ended that later readers, on the one hand, are stopped from peering behind them to one or more clearly definable sets of circumstances or settings in life, and on the other hand,
An HIV and AIDS gender-sensitive biblical hermeneutic is first and foremost contextual. It seriously takes into account the experiences of HIV and AIDS women sufferers. As African women are the hardest hit by the pandemic of HIV and AIDS in South Africa, our HIV and AIDS gender-conscious re-reading of Psalm 6 will be informed first and foremost by the experiences of these women. Before we give a brief overview of African women’s experiences, the following narrative is in order.
In December 2014, Madipoane Masenya (ngwan’a Mphahlele) participated in an HIV and AIDS workshop which occurred at McCormick Theological Seminary in Chicago, IL, USA. One of the keynote speakers was the Rev. Dr Jeremiah Wright, Bishop Emeritus at the Trinity Church in Chicago. While Dr Wright commended South Africa (cf. at least compared to the USA) for the strides the country has made regarding the fight against HIV and AIDS, he also added a critique. Dr Wright noted that it was in South Africa that the President is reported to have cleansed himself from the HIV in a shower! Although the preceding critique could be viewed as based on an issue that may be deemed to belong to the dustbin of history, an important question we ask is: what may the institution of polygyny contribute to our communal struggle in the fight against the pandemic of HIV and AIDS? Although it might be argued that the (mostly younger) women who are now South Africa’s many first ladies were not coerced into such a risky form of marriage in the HIV and AIDS context, the initiators of marriage in our patriarchal African contexts are usually men. The critique by Dr Wright above serves as a fitting introduction to the topic of the present article, that is, the act of dangling between death and hope as a people both infected and affected by HIV and AIDS: Death in the sense that factors such as dangerous masculinities (cf. polygyny and engaging in unprotected sex among others), but also hope in the sense that the country has, since the so-called Thabo Mbeki’s denialism dispensation, made strides of success in her fight against HIV and AIDS.
As scholars within the South African Biblical sciences though, we need to hasten to argue that we cannot own the success that has been made so far. Why? Very little, if any, biblical scholarship in South Africa integrates HIV and AIDS studies in their disciplines, yet, as Dube (
In the HIV and AIDS context, where about sixty million members of the world have been infected, with a third of these dead and 15 million children orphaned, where the social justice and human rights link are so central, the classy, text-centred academic biblical approach is challenged to expand its boundaries. It becomes evident that it is an approach that is vulnerable to silence and indifference to the social concerns of its world and communities. It becomes evident that, many times, academic biblical studies largely becomes research for the sake of research, whose findings hardly ever seek to inform social practice and social transformation. (p. 506)
Like many Circle of Concerned African Women Theologians (hereinafter referred to as Circle), we argue in this article that there is a link between the pandemic of HIV and AIDS and patriarchy, poverty and non-literacy among others. HIV and AIDS is thus a justice issue. We also acknowledge that on the African continent and its diaspora, HIV and AIDS carries a feminine face. As such, and as already noted, we will deliberately approach the topic of this article, as far as it is possible, informed by the experiences of African–South African women – who are the hardest hit by the pandemic of HIV and AIDS. In our view, the pandemic, like the event of exile in biblical Israel, has thrown African people into a moment of crisis. The moment of crisis calls for a lament not only of affected individuals but a communal lament. Commenting on the works (read: lament) of Circle African women theologians, Dube (
These expressions are a scream, a clarion call, a lament for transforming the world towards justice for, to and with all members of the earth’s community. These expositions underlie that injustice in any form, to any member of the earth’s community, is at the end of the day, the root cause of ill-health. They expose that gender oppression is incontrovertibly violent to both sexes. They underline the fact that poverty might be perpetuated by a few world powers and national leaders, but it is, irreducibly, violence to those who are dehumanized through poverty, violence that cannot be restricted to certain spaces and people, but one that always finds a way of spilling over into the safe havens of the rich and the powerful. (p. 175)
We will thus engage the lament of Psalm 6, from an HIV and AIDS gender perspective. Within the South African context, it should be noted with Masenya (ngwan’a Mphahlele) (2010) that due to a variety of factors which have contributed to the marginalisation of African women, the HIV and AIDS pandemic has only come to exacerbate their situation
The demonisation of African cultures by colonial masters and many a missionary who colluded with the colonials, apartheid teachers and preachers is well-documented (cf. Dube
… it is too easy to lay the blame solely at the feet of westernization. We know that in the African religio-cultural heritage is to be found the seeds of objectification and marginalization of women. Colonial policies simply helped the process along, and it succeeded to the extent that it was advantageous for African men. (p. 173)
One therefore does not need to be born in pre-colonial Africa to agree that even before the white man landed with his European patriarchy on the African shores, he already found one on the African continent. In that sense, while the situation of African women was already limping on account of patriarchy, the new systems, that is, colonialism and apartheid in the case of South Africa, only made it to climb a mountain. As an African woman’s situation was intensified by patriarchy within the broader South African context, an African man became emasculated.
It will be an exaggeration to argue that there were no poor people in pre-colonial Africa. Proverbs and wisdom sayings, which refer to orphans and poor people, as well as the care which they were supposed to receive from their communities throw light on the existence of the preceding category of people (cf. also Masenya [ngwan’a Mphahlele]
In the process of ‘Africa being underdeveloped by Europe’ to use part of the title of Rodney’s book, (cf. Rodney 2009), African peoples were stripped of their lands even as they were forced into a new system of labour to earn the new form of money (cf. Mofokeng
The preceding scenario reminds us of an African-American context. In their book titled
With respect to the South African context, statistics reveal that among cases of sexual violation against women reported to the police, a higher proportion of 55.3% was said to have been committed by strangers (Hirschowitz, Worku & Orkin
Among white women interviewed in the survey, 7.3% reported being raped. This was the largest percentage within each population group, followed by coloureds (6%) … When calculated as a proportion of the total number of women who had reported being raped (
Based on the preceding remark, it may be argued that violence against women is a perturbing reality in South Africa. The link between gender-based violence and HIV and AIDS is irrefutable as many a woman contracts the virus in the event of rape. Masenya (ngwan’a Mphahlele) (
Furthermore, Sociologist Benjamin P. Bowser proposes that men of all social classes who experience frustrated instrumental and social roles put more stress on sexuality (Bowser
Chitando and Chirongoma (
The male quest for sexual pleasure has had negative consequences, for women, children and men themselves in the era of HIV. Although there are factors that facilitate the spread of HIV, including poverty, migrant labour, international justice and others, patterns of male sexual behavior require urgent attention…Unfortunately, many men strive to live up to the ideal of competence and conquest in the area of sexuality. Most men do not invest in intimacy. They regard sex as a form of entertainment wherein they must be the ones who derive maximum satisfaction. Men have been pampered to believe that their egos must be massaged, and that they must always have things their own way. (pp. 58–59)
Such problematic definitions of masculinities can easily be made to collude with those of their kind found within biblical texts. If these are not sanctioned by life-affirming biblical hermeneutics and theologies (a rare type even in the post-apartheid South African context), particularly in the era of HIV and AIDS, our struggle against the pandemic is far from being won.
The lamentable state of affairs about the glaring inequalities between women and men in the South African church, family and society at large has been ‘made to climb a mountain’ today by the prevalence of the deadly pandemic of HIV and AIDS. African women scholars, particularly members of the Circle, have spilled a lot of ink on the gendered nature of the pandemic (cf. Dube & Kayoro
Some of the above-mentioned Circle theologians further revealed that harmful cultural and religious practices also contribute to the spread of HIV among African women (cf. Ayanga
With the preceding brief background to some of the challenges facing African–South African women in the era of HIV and AIDS, also having been enabled to situate our gender-sensitive HIV and AIDS hermeneutic in context, we now offer a gender-sensitive HIV and AIDS re-reading of Psalm 6, a lament psalm from a sick person (cf. Habtu
If there is any major crisis that ancient Israel ever came to experience, that was the crisis brought by her experience of the exile. The moment was typified by death (in the literal and metaphorical sense) or war or the sword, pestilence (read: disease) and famine. The moment of exile was at the same time typified by hope as some of the prophets could prophesy both doom (read: death) and salvation (read: hope) (cf. for example Isaiah and Hosea in the preceding category). Even a prophet of doom such as Jeremiah has scattered within his prophetic tradition prophecies of hope and return.
It would not be an exaggeration to argue that during the transition between the period before exile and the Babylonian exile itself, the nation was trapped between death and hope. Theirs was a dispensation that called for lament and in particular a communal lament. Is it any wonder that the Psalter, one of the influential literatures in the Hebrew Bible, is replete with psalms of lament, that is, both the individual and communal laments? Although some of the psalms originated within a pre-exilic setting, in the context of exile and a post-exilic setting, such psalms would have assumed a different meaning. Worthy of note is the observation that also within these psalms of lament, a creative tension between doubt (read: hopelessness or doom) and faith (read: hope) is maintained. Such a tension had to be maintained because as Mandolfo (
together, these two ideological positions – doubt and faith – offer a profound reflection on human experience. Faith without doubt is myopic; while doubt without faith runs the danger of sliding into existential meaninglessness. (p. 125)
What is heartening though is that for those who have ears to hear and eyes to see, it was clear that even amidst the crisis, there was already light at the end of the tunnel. We now turn to the lament in the book of Psalms.
In our view, what would draw gender-sensitive scholars to the Psalter as a whole is that, unlike the prophetic corpus that seems to have been the preoccupation of a few people, mostly men, the Psalter is a storehouse of a variety that forms the package we call human experience. The fact that we cannot lay hold on the identity of the original psalmist who uttered the words of the lament of Psalm 6 may not bother an HIV and AIDS gender-identified reader of the psalm. In our view, what matters most, is the apparent resonance of the content of the lament with the present day experiences of HIV and AIDS sufferers
One feels helpless, oppressed by forces outside oneself – and indeed that is the situation. Moaning, groaning, sighing, tears, the experience, Why is this happening to me? – all are aspects of the distress of sickness. (p. 26)
It is an indisputable fact that feminist scholars use human (read: female) experience as a point of departure in their hermeneutical endeavours (Fontaine
On the other hand, Nancy L. Declaissé-Walford (
Thus, on account of the psalms’ timeless and open-ended nature, Psalm 6 can also be appropriated by present day AIDS sufferers.
In the context of HIV and AIDS, the pray-er or sufferer or lamenter is first and foremost a believer, a Christian woman who may not necessarily have the medical resources to take care of her severe sickness (read: opportunistic diseases caused by AIDS). The lamenter would most probably be women whose cd count had gone so low that their bodies would be deteriorating day in and day out (Ps 6:2). Although their physical bodies are failing them, their spirits are still alive and their faith in God still intact (Ps 6). Unlike many fellow believers including both clergy and laity, who had told them that they contracted the virus because of their sins, these women, like the lamenter in Psalm 6, are not persuaded that they are sick because they had sinned, hence no confession of sin as the lament of Psalm 6 opens.
On account of the severity of the psalmist’s condition
In our view, unlike the lamenter in Psalm6 who did not believe that God could still be praised by believers after death (read: in Sheol
As already noted with Miller above, any condition of (severe) sickness has the capacity to lead the victim to a state of helplessness and even hopelessness. What exacerbates the situation of HIV and AIDS sufferers, particularly in our African Christian contexts are the following factors among others: the association of the pandemic with sex and sexuality. The engagement with the preceding themes is a taboo within various African contexts (cf. Kathide
Within the context of the crisis brought by HIV and AIDS, the following prayer items would in our view form the gist of the individual lament. To use the language of the psalmist, such items among others may be viewed as some of the enemies she has to grapple with: (1) the stigma around HIV and AIDS, one which keeps the infected isolated even by members of their faith communities. We are here reminded of the words of Beverly Haddad (
In a moment of crisis, a poor African woman does not have the capacity to spend money on a well-balanced diet and medicine among others. As she dangles between death and hope, she is sustained by her faith in the God who hears and answers prayer. Indeed the lament psalms display faith under the most contrary circumstances (cf. Broyles 2008:396). Her ability to see beyond her poverty and her worn-out body enables her to dare to dream even in her moment of crisis. As has been argued by Graic Broyles: ‘Assumed here is that God can be moved not only emotionally, as expressed in the laments, but also by reason and by argument’ (Broyles 2008:396). In Psalm 6, for example, the appeal is threefold. Firstly, it pits Yahweh’s ‘loyalty’ (
O Lord, do not rebuke me in your anger, or discipline me in your wrath. (Oh Lord, spare me from your heated wrath, your anger overwhelms me)
Be gracious to me, O LORD, for I am languishing; O LORD, heal me, for my bones are shaking with terror. (Carrying an AIDS-ravaged body, I feel exhausted, hasn’t hunger also taken its toll on me? Have mercy…)
My soul also is struck with terror, while you, O LORD - how long? (For how Long, will I have to suffer, my soul deeply unsettled, why should the innocent righteous suffer?)
Turn, O LORD, save my life; deliver me for the sake of your steadfast love. (Remember my poverty, my plight, in your loving kindness redeem me from this body of death)
For in death there is no remembrance of you; in Sheol who can give you praise? (Does Sheol know any remembrance of you, No it doesn’t! So, save me…)
I am weary with my moaning; every night I flood my bed with tears; I drench my couch with my weeping. (My tears are my food, exhaustion my lot, My God, ill- health is wearing me off)
My eyes waste away because of grief; they grow weak because of all my foes. (My enemies, stigma, poverty, patriarchy, Empire, detached political and religious leaders, overwhelm my body with grief)
Depart from me, all you workers of evil, for the LORD has heard the sound of my weeping. (In your loving kindness oh Lord, you have heard my prayer, you evil systems, you violators of female bodies, you, even you can never have a hold over me! Go away!)
The LORD has heard my supplication; the LORD accepts my prayer. (Amidst death, I have hope, the Lord has heard my prayer, I am thus alive!)
All my enemies shall be ashamed and struck with terror; they shall turn back, and in a moment be put to shame. (To my enemies, shame on you!)
In the preceding text, Psalm 6 in the New Revised Standard Version is presented, followed by our re-reading form. The reconstruction of the biblical text using the language and concepts which are relevant to a particular context, is not a new phenomenon in African Biblical hermeneutics. In his proposal of the creation of religious texts, Snyman (
As already noted, the sufferer in our re-reading of Psalm 6 is not only sick, he is very sick, thus nearing death. What would be fascinating to present day African readers of this lament is that the man who was crying out the lament did not shy away from crying out to God. In the midst of any crisis, what counts the most is not that a particular gender is the one to blame and thus to suffer, what is more urgent is that human life, whether male or female, rich or poor, black or white among others, is at stake. Human life is threatened. One is injured. So all are and should be equally injured. Walking in the shadow of the valley of death on account of his physical, emotional and psychological health among others, did not deter the psalmist from holding on to a stubborn hope. Amidst death-dealing situations such as the one in which we all have been thrown into by the pandemic of HIV and AIDS, as well as hopelessness, a lament can serve as a vehicle for the down-trodden, the sufferers, the justice-seekers to remain sustained, to dare to dream because, argues Katongole (
… a biblically inspired social engagement in the era of HIV/AIDS, rather than being grounded in an activist paradigm, needs to grow out of, and be deeply connected to, a biblically inspired discipline of lament. The reason for this has to do not only with the fact that the stubbornness to dream of God’s new creation in the wake of AIDS involves the discipline of sustained memory, but also with the realization that dreaming is deeply engaged commitment that requires community. (p. 41)
The authors declare that they have no financial or personal relationships which may have inappropriately influenced them in writing this article.
M.M. and V.N.N.M. of the University of South Africa were project leaders and as such, they were responsible for the conceptual contributions.
In this sense, while it was limping, HIV and AIDS made African women to climb the mountain! The Northern Sotho proverb,
According to Okure, humanity as a whole, both black and white, men and women, has been limping from time immemorial (2003:71–95). She asserts: ‘So it is with patriarchy and humanity. From the time of Genesis 3, humanity has been limping. Though divinely inspired, Genesis 3 itself has been written from the perspective of the limping humanity. The story of the fall grows out of the biblical author’s awareness that the situation by which the woman is treated as the man’s property and dominated by the man in all walks of life is a result of sin, not the created order willed by God’ (Okure
‘Now therefore, thus says the Lord, the God of Israel, concerning this city of which you say, “It shall be delivered into the hand of the king of Babylon by the sword, and by famine, and by pestilence”: See, I will gather them out of all countries wherever I have driven them in My anger, and in My fury, and in great wrath; and I will bring them again to this place, and I will cause them to dwell safely. And they shall be My people, and I will be their God. And I will give them one heart and one way, that they may fear Me forever, for their good and for their children after them’ (Jeremiah 32:36–39 MEV).
In a more or less similar vein, Goldingay (
We therefore beg to differ with Habtu when he argues that ‘His(the Psalmist) experience shows that suffering can indeed be God’s discipline …’ (Habtu
Like Psalms 38, 41, 88 and 102, Psalm 6 is the prayer of a very sick person (Habtu
In Hebrew thought, Sheol is the grave, a place of murky silence. It is a place of no return with little or no contact with Yahweh (Ps 94:17; Ps 143:3; Job 7:9), and thus no possibility for praising God there. The concern for healing and deliverance by the lamenter in Psalm 6 makes sense against such a background. Only very late in the postexilic age was the notion of God’s presence with the dead in Sheol accepted (Ps 139:8). Belief in life after death is found earlier on within popular religious beliefs (1 Sm 28:8–25; 2 Ki 2:11; Stuhlmueller